Plant Genetics

The Genetic Clues That Separate Fiber Hemp From Drug-Type Cannabis

·

Fiber hemp stalks and a branching cannabis specimen on a laboratory table.

A long, relatively unbranched stem is valuable when the harvest is fiber. A plant with many flowering shoots presents a different kind of harvest. Those contrasting forms invite a simple historical story: people favored different plants and their crops gradually grew apart. Genetics offers a way to investigate that story, but it takes two kinds of comparison to distinguish the ancestry of a crop from the history of a particular trait.

A researcher can first compare plants at thousands of positions scattered across their DNA. That shows which samples tend to resemble one another broadly. The next step is to look for short stretches where the contrast is especially pronounced. A convincing pattern in the first analysis does not tell the investigator in advance which genes will turn up in the second.

The broad family resemblance

In a genetic survey of hemp and drug-type cannabis, investigators compared 81 drug-type samples and 43 hemp samples at more than fourteen thousand variable positions. The groups differed across the genome. The distinction extended well beyond the small part of the plant’s chemistry that produces THC. A blind comparison of sufficiently many markers could therefore recover information about the breeding populations the plants came from.

A genome-wide resemblance is partly the result of who had offspring with whom. Once people repeatedly save seed from a restricted group, variants can become common simply through shared ancestry and chance. A feature that distinguishes two groups today need never have caught the eye of a farmer. That is why finding a difference, even a striking one, is only the beginning of a case for selection.

Following the evidence into the stalk

A later whole-genome investigation of 110 cannabis accessions searched for stretches of DNA bearing signatures of selection. The researchers compared populations, examined local patterns of variation and considered the biological jobs of genes within the candidate regions. Some candidates in improved hemp were associated with branch formation, flowering time or the production of cellulose and lignin, two important components of plant cell walls.

It is easy to see why such results attracted attention. Fiber is a physical product with a location in the stem. Branches interrupt that stem, and the tissues a plant builds help determine what can be recovered from it. A review of the anatomy of fiber-bearing stems offers a view from the other end of the process: anatomical differences can be examined directly rather than inferred from a DNA sequence.

A gene in the right neighborhood with the right-sounding job is still a candidate. When one version of a useful gene becomes more common, nearby variants can travel with it because neighboring DNA is often inherited together. Narrowing down which change affected a stem would require evidence connecting that change to a measurable trait. Genetic geography gives a researcher somewhere to look; it cannot supply the missing measurement.

The chemistry has its own family history

Cannabinoids add another layer. Enzymes help turn a shared precursor into the acidic forms associated with THC and CBD. The genome study found patterns consistent with loss of function in genes involved in these competing routes during the divergence of crop types. A physical and genetic map of cannabis reveals extensive rearrangements around the genes for these enzymes. A comparison of apparently equivalent stretches of DNA can therefore be misleading.

It follows that two sensible questions about the same specimen can have different answers. Which reference population does it resemble across its genome? What chemical profile does this particular flower actually show? A broad ancestry estimate can survive a change at one influential region, while chemistry can respond quite strongly to it. Measuring a flower and tracing its relatives are complementary ways of describing the plant.

Neither analysis records a farmer deciding which stalks to keep. The closest we can come is to bring several lines of evidence into agreement: relatedness across whole genomes, unusual patterns around particular genes, and the structure or chemistry of the plants themselves. A long stem that comes apart into usable fibers was a trait someone could handle and value centuries before there was a name for the genes that helped produce it.